I could go on for awhile with the metallic puns, but I’m going to pass up this
golden opportunity and just talk about how weird and wonderful it is all of a sudden to listen to professional sports chat.
But first a quick update, for those of you who don’t care/are too busy to pay attention to the NBA/aren’t sure which sport the NBA involves/don’t live with partners who watch a lot of ESPN/think that ESPN stands for something to do with Spain:
There’s this 84 year-old rich guy, Donald Sterling, okay? Very rich: billionaire rich. Owns a basketball team rich. The LA Clippers, to be precise. Also the kind of rich who can apparently have both a wife AND a 31 year-old girlfriend without that being a news story in itself.
Last week someone (who? Who? Ooooh, news story!) recorded a private phone call between Sterling and said girlfriend, V. Stiviano, in which he berated her for posting pictures on her Instagram account of herself standing with “minorities” .
Those “minorities”? Among others, current NBA star Blake Griffin and NBA LEGEND/philanthropic entrepreneur Magic Johnson. To Mr. Sterling, they are just “black people.”
Here is the transcript of the tape, as offered by Deadspin.com (which also has video):
V: I don’t understand, I don’t see your views. I wasn’t raised the way you were raised.
DS: Well then, if you don’t feel—don’t come to my games. Don’t bring black people, and don’t come.
V: Do you know that you have a whole team that’s black, that plays for you?
DS: You just, do I know? I support them and give them food, and clothes, and cars, and houses. Who gives it to them? Does someone else give it to them?Do I know that I have—Who makes the game? Do I make the game, or do they make the game? Is there 30 owners, that created the league?
Poor Los Angeles Dodgers outfielder Matt Kemp is also dragged into the conversation, having appeared in an Instagram photo with V. Stiviano. It was her photo with Magic Johnson that had apparently started the fight.
V: Honey, if it makes you happy, I will remove all of the black people from my Instagram.
DS: You said that before, you said, “I understand.”
V: I DID remove the people that were independently on my Instagram that are black.
DS: Then why did you start saying that you didn’t? You just said that you didn’t remove them. You didn’t remove every—
V: I didn’t remove Matt Kemp and Magic Johnson, but I thought—
V: I thought Matt Kemp is mixed, and he was OK, just like me.
V: He’s lighter and whiter than me.
V: I met his mother.
DS: You think I’m a racist, and wouldn’t—
V: I don’t think you’re a racist.
DS: Yes you do. Yes you do.
V: I think you, you—
DS: Evil heart.
And there is also this baffling exchange about black Jews in Israel:
DS: It’s the world! You go to Israel, the blacks are just treated like dogs.
V: So do you have to treat them like that too?
DS: The white Jews, there’s white Jews and black Jews, do you understand?
V: And are the black Jews less than the white Jews?
DS: A hundred percent, fifty, a hundred percent.
V: And is that right?
DS: It isn’t a question—we don’t evaluate what’s right and wrong, we live in a society. We live in a culture. We have to live within that culture.
V: But shouldn’t we take a stand for what’s wrong? And be the change and the difference?
DS: I don’t want to change the culture, because I can’t. It’s too big and too [unknown].
V: But you can change yourself.
DS: I don’t want to change. If my girl can’t do what I want, I don’t want the girl. I’ll find a girl that will do what I want! Believe me. I thought you were that girl—because I tried to do what you want. But you’re not that girl.
They close by essentially invoking Hitler and closing down the thread, comparing Sterling’s viewpoints to the Holocaust:
V: It’s like saying, “Let’s just persecute and kill all of the Jews.”
DS: Oh, it’s the same thing, right?
V: Isn’t it wrong? Wasn’t it wrong then? With the Holocaust? And you’re Jewish, you understand discrimination.
DS: You’re a mental case, you’re really a mental case. The Holocaust, we’re comparing with—
V: Racism! Discrimination.
DS: There’s no racism here. If you don’t want to be… walking… into a basketball game with a certain… person, is that racism?
Thank you, Deadspin.com. Seeing this down in black and white, along with your commentary…well, I’m not sure if it’s more chilling than disgusting, or vice versa.
SO. Between Saturday and Tuesday, ESPN and all the other sports chatterers erupted into a conflagration of righteous anger that was beautiful to behold. “Round-Mound-of-Rebound” Charles Barkley, now a commentator, said it “pisses me off” to know that Sterling greets him happily in public but still thinks of him as a lesser human being, and doesn’t see anything wrong with that attitude. (You heard the man, right? “There’s no racism here.”)
On Tuesday, brand-spanking new NBA Commissioner Adam Silver (who, it must be said, looks an awful lot like Dobby the House-Elf), announced the NBA’s response. Donald Sterling is banned from the NBA for life, meaninghe can never attend another game ANYwhere. He must pay a 2.5 million-dollar fine (the highest that can be assessed). And Silver himself will pressure the other NBA owners to force Sterling to sell the team.
In other words: whatever else you want to complain about, in terms of our Moneyball sports culture, we have achieved this progress: we ALL AGREE that RACISM IS REPUGNANT.
The reaction among the sports chatterers has been one of authentic relief, pride, and yes, joy. I can’t get enough of it. Finally…we’re talking about something REAL here! We’re discussing the importance of human dignity in the workplace! We’re drawing parallels between “minorities” and women! We are sounding full-on progressive.
I know pretty soon it’ll all die down and I’ll go back to being annoyed by cheerleaders, badly-behaved spoiled stars, and coverage of things like the Masters golf tournament that still excludes women and still plays on a course with a proud history of excluding both women and people of color. But for now, I want to celebrate Adam Silver, the NBA, and this moment of joy in the power of standing up for what’s decent.
Care to tune in? What do you make of this moment in sports history? What does it say to you?
I am thoroughly and totally disgusted by this display of racism. Still, I’m leery of the legality of this retribution based on thoughts, not his actions. I know he’s filfthy loaded and this is merely a slap on the wrist to him. And I don’t agree with his views at all. He’s arrogant, racist, and bigoted, but this is still America. Thinking and speaking like a jackass is still legal. Worthy of public criticism and banning and fining from an organization upholding its standards? Definitely. But forcing him to sell his business? Hmmmm… Okay, again the business is part of said organization upholding its standards. But it’s pushing the thought police mentality. Has he actually done anything illegal? We need to be careful that we’re punishing crimes, not opinions.
Ironically, of course, it was the person who recorded the phone call who was breaking the law! So who knows what, if anything, of this sad affair will stand up in court, and Mr. Sterling would be well in his rights to sue whoever did the recording. (For what does a billionaire sue, though?) My reaction comes less from the “oh good he’s being punished” aspect and more from the “hooray, we all agree that we have to do SOMETHING” aspect, which, for ONCE, allows rich athletes and mindless-seeming commentators to talk about something that seems meaningful in the larger scheme of things.
In this case, I believe the public airing of those views is probably punishment enough, as Mr. Sterling will now become a pariah.
As always, thanks for the comments!
Hopefully the whole thing will force Mr. Sterling to think through his prejudices and seek out a little truth. But with that much money, who needs it? Unfortunately, he can afford to be a bigot and a pariah.
Reading the transcript, I had a thought I’ve had before. I found Sterling’s conversation to be on the incoherent side, and, given his age, I wonder if there’s some degree of dementia involved.
Now, I am certainly not condoning his attitudes – all other things aside, there’s something repugnant to me in an employer belittling the employees who are lining his coffers no matter what the reason. And bigotry such as that he displays is something the world will be better without.
I just wonder if he really, truly, knows what he’s saying…some instinct, maybe the part that worked with a number of Alzheimer’s sufferers) says he may not be fully in charge of his mental capacities.
But I’m totally with you that the discussion is valuable, and will hopefully lead to a deeper understanding of the damage these attitudes can cause.
And that is a good thing that can come of this!
Everyone familiar with the guy seemed to think his comments were in complete keeping with stuff they’ve heard from him before, so…if it’s dementia, it’s apparently been going on a long, long time. Of course that is a kind of “demented” attitude, so…
But yes. It is good to be thinking ahead on this. It’s funny: 2 weeks before this whole episode I wrote a song, called “Launched,” dedicated to the 20-somethings in my life (including my kids), which includes these lines: “Sorry about college, how it burdened you with debt/Sorry that we haven’t conquered racism just yet…” And then, proving my point, enter Mr. Sterling. 🙂
From what I have read, his racist attitudes were a well known secret. He has been sued any number of times re: his discriminatory practices in real estate. The NBA did nothing because it did not impact basketball. This time, it did impact basketball. I don’t see him fading away. I think there will be long legal battles.
Melissa, you are probably right. Sigh. But I’m still glad for the public stink, because we all agree it DOES stink.